Below you can watch the debate after our journalists were joined by star names from the sporting world to discuss the matter at hand.
Commentator Barry Davies, former sprinter Darren Campbell, Olympic hockey champion Alex Danson, hugely successful Paralympian Baroness Grey-Thompson and two-time Olympic rowing gold medalist James Cracknell sat alongside Sir Ian McGeechan, Marcus Armytage, Simon Briggs, Jason Burt and host Jim White for an enthralling debate on a fiercely contested field.